"The Critic"
movie reviews movie review
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer Bio

Upda
A

Search Movie Review Archives

0-9 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
 
About DVDivas
Dvdivas was founded by John Gabbard in 2000. It's purpose has been and remains to be to provide you, the entertainment community with the latest dvds and movie reviews. It will continue to be your link to the most popular dvd movies.

 

Paul McCartney - The Music and Animation Collection
Reviewed by: Wayne Klein
Genre: Animation
Video: Widescreen anamorphic 1.85:1
Audio: Dolby Digital 5.1
Languages English
Subtitles English, Spanish
Length 43 minutes
Rating NR
Release Date 4/13/04
Studio Miramax Home Video
Commentary: None
Documentaries: None
Featurettes: Making of "Tropic Island Hum; " Making of " Tuesday"
Filmography/Biography: None
Interviews: Paul McCartney
Trailers/TV Spots: None
Alternate/Deleted Scenes: None
Music Video: None
Other: Storyboard and Line Test drawings for all three shorts; Layout drawings; 16 page color booklet with sketches, song lyrics and background on each short
Cast and Crew: Dustin Hoffman, Paul McCartney, Amanda Massa, Robert Stanger, Windsor Davies, June Whitfield
Written By: Amanda Massa, Robert Stanger, Geoff Dunbar, Linda McCartney, Paul McCartney
Produced By: Paul McCartney, Jacqui Davies, Judith Roberts
Directed By: Geoff Dunbar
Music: Paul McCartney
The Review:

Sir Paul more than gets by with a little help from his friends in this collection of animated shorts directed by the UK's Geoff Dunbar. Combining traditional cel animation with CGI, Dunbar brings to life three tales that McCartney wrote the music for starting in 1983 ("Rupert and the Frog Song") through to the present ("Tuesday" and "Tropic Island Hum"). Dunbar's whimsical design and charming direction keep these tales hopping. Capturing the spirit of Disney's own Winnie the Pooh shorts from the 60's but with a much more contemporary feel, these three short films recall the glory day of hand drawn animation with its attention to detail in the design and look of the films. ***

The three tales come from a variety of sources. The first has an ecological theme and is an original tale created by McCartney called "Tropic Island Hum". Froggo rescues Whirral the squirrel from hunters in his fabulous hot air balloon. Froggo whisks Whirral away to a tropical island sanctuary filled with similar animals driven away from their home by humans. McCartney's winning music with a nice orchestral arrangement by Beatles producer George Martin is one of many highlights in this tale. ***

The second film "Rupert and the Frog Song" won the BAFTA (British Academy Award) when it was released in theaters in 1983 and features the popular English character of Rupert the white bear. Rupert in his search for a playmate follows a group of frogs underground. Rupert becomes caught up in the celebration of the Frog King and Queen's anniversary. Again, the sharp design and full animation along with the story will charm little ones. McCartney wrote a song specifically for this short which became a hit single in the UK. ***

"Tuesday" adapted from writer David Wiesner's popular children's book focuses on the havoc in the human world when a group of frogs mysteriously rise and fly out of a swamp to plaque humanity. The humorous and intriguing tale has a nice twist to the end and McCartney's score perfectly compliments director Dunbar's sharp direction. The combination of traditional cel animation with CGI along with the colorful design work makes "Tuesday" a unique animated short. ---

Image and Sound: The marvelously detailed transfer vividly brings these animated classics to life. Dunbar's unique designs and the rich animation benefit from the beautifully and flawless DVD images. The 5.1 Surround Sound mix helps bring these fun and witty shorts to life. McCartney's music sounds rich and colorful in the carefully laid out sound mix. ---
The Extras:

There's a marvelous (although short) interview with McCartney where he talks about the impact that the Disney classics had on him as a child. Additionally, he discusses what attracted him to such an unusual venture as well as the collaborative nature of working with Dunbar. The storyboards and line drawings give one a greater appreciation of the difficult task that Dunbar faced. While this type of traditional animation has fallen from favor, it's still an art form that needs to be appreciated. ***

The difficult and arduous work of transferring Dunbar's line drawings to animation cels and the unusual approach used to make the mysterious "Tuesday" are also highlights of this well thought out extras package. Since two of the three animated shorts come with exhaustive "Making of" featurettes we get a very involved look at the process of creating animated shorts like these. All three have extras focusing on the line drawings, layout artwork and/or storyboards that, again, provide a unique glimpse inside the mysterious process of creating animated shorts. ***

We're also treated to a 16 page deluxe booklet. The beautifully designed booklet features artwork from the shorts, a brief background on McCartney's involvement in the project and biography of director Dunbar. We also get a glimpse at many of the design drawings, sketches and storyboards used to create these three animated classics. The snapcase comes with a nice cardboard slipcase as well. This truly is a class act from beginning to end. Clearly McCartney's devotion to helping others create and to film hasn't diminished over time. While he's had a couple of disasters in his long career ("Give My Regards to Broadstreet"), he's also learned to turn over the creative reins to others when necessary. ***

McCartney's interview might be expected to overshadow a project of this nature. Surprisingly, it doesn't as he's quite generous in giving credit where it's due. While he does give the background in the interview as to what prompted him to delve into animation in the first place, he recognizes that these are primarily Dunbar's babies (with considerable input from Sir Paul naturally). McCartney and his wife Linda were very involved in creating the Rupert short coming up with the story in collaboration with Dunbar. While McCartney's involvement in the other two shorts varied a bit, all three have a combination of his unmistakable stamp along with Dunbar's unique vision as a director. ---

Commentary: There's no commentary from any of the artists involved in the production of these shorts. It's a pity as McCartney would have been able to provide an interesting perspective on writing music for an animated film. Dunbar's comments on the challenges of making "Tuesday" and working with a popular and demanding artist like McCartney also would have been a highlight of the disc. ---
Final Words: A charming and delightful find, this collection is a must have for fans of classic Disney animation. All three shorts have their own unique character and are as varied as can be in their design and stories. The fluid animation, delightful design and beautiful transfer are all highlights of the disc. While all three could have comfortably fit on a single layer disc, this is a dual layer taking advantage of the full storage capacity allowing for a beautiful, sharp and flaw free transfer.

 

 
 
 
Copyright @ Teakwood Productions 2000
Home News DVDWorld DVDLand(Links) DVDVoices
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer's Bio
Upcoming DVDs In Theatres Soon Other Popular Reviews
This Page Design By Dominion Technology Provider
 
In Theatres Soon Upcoming DVDs Alias Tomb Raider Casablanca NYPD Blues