movie reviews movie review
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer Bio


Search Movie Review Archives

0-9 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
 
About DVDivas
Dvdivas was founded by John Gabbard in 2000. It's purpose has been and remains to be to provide you, the entertainment community with the latest dvds and movie reviews. It will continue to be your link to the most popular dvd movies.

 

“Star Trek: The Original Series-Season 1” {Blu-ray} - (Wayne's Review)
Reviewer:
Wayne Klein
Studio: CBS/Paramount Home Video
Genre:
TV-Series
Release Date:
4/26/09
Special Features:

Enterprise Exterior Tour, “Starfleet Access” Interactive feature with interviews, “Spacelife: Transporting Trek into the 21st Century”, “Star Trek: Beyond the Final Frontier” documentary, “Trekker Connections”, “To Boldly Go”, “Sci-Fi Visionaries”, “Kiss and Tell: Romance in the 23rd Century”, “Birth of a Timeless Legacy”, “Reflections on Spock”, “Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner” ---

Review:

"CBS/Paramount", continues to milk the “Star Trek” cow and the udders are still delivering.We’re living in the future today. Don’t believe me? Look at the communicators in “Star Trek” which use the Enterprise as a GPS to locate crew and beam them. Look at half a dozen examples in “Star Trek” and you’ll see that we live in the future . Luckily, human behavior hasn’t changed and that’s the charm of “Star Trek” that, along with top notch acting (for the most part) and top notch writing (for the most part). CBS seems to have finally gotten it right with the Blu-ray for “Star Trek” and it’s only taken four attempts; the first season was released to DVD two episodes per disc. Then it was released in a season set in these horrible clam shell packages. Next up, we had these easily breakable remastered three seasons with new visual effects. Fans had complaints about all of these and they were justified. I guess the fourth time is the charm after all (yes, I know the third time is usually the charm but this is the future after all and things do change). Just a note on my opinion of this set—it’s a little more valid than some other reviews because I actually had to BUY this as Paramount wouldn’t provide us with a promo copy to review. ***

“Star Trek” still continues to be the standard against which most science fiction TV dramas are measured and rightly so—the writing, direction and acting was unusually rich in a time when juvenile plots were the focus in other similar shows such as “Lost in Space”, “Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea”, “Time Tunnel” and other shows (although admittedly the first season of just about any Irwin Allen show was usually good it’s when subsequent seasons appeared that the shows declined and rapidly). I love the first season more than others because there’s plenty of conflict and humor. The characters get along most of the time but not all of the time. Later, Gene Roddenberry wanted a harmonious, perfect crew. That didn’t occur with the second season either although it was closer to what he wanted. One of the few flaws of “Star Trek: The Next Generation” is the fact that everyone got along too well. That isn’t the case with the first season and the bulk of the second for the original series. ---

Image & Sound:

“Star Trek” looks extremely good with nice detail, rich color and the image isn’t over processed—there’s plenty of film grain evident and skin textures look completely natural. Some shots look better than others depending on the condition of the original negatives. There’s only so much clean up that any software can do and, well, CBS has done a terrific job here but keep in mind this was made in 1966 and 1967. Occasionally the images are soft for example with close ups of the main actors but that’s usually a choice of the D.P. and the director as used filters to soften the image. ***

I can’t compare this directly to the HD/DVD set from last year but from memory it does look like the Blu-ray actually has a sharper picture. Perhaps CBS used the time to do some additional work on the series but I suspect it has more to do with the format itself. ***

The rumor about the show being retooled for widescreen are false—this is presented in the original 4:3 aspect ratio which is appropriate given that otherwise it would stretch and distort the image. ***

The red of Scotty’s shirt is quite deep and the blues are quite rich looking. ***

Audio sounds quite good with a nice 7.1 mix lossless remix featuring the original dialog, music and with sound effects added (all vintage sounding just re-recorded and repurposed for other channels). Dialog remains clean and clear throughout and the music sounds quite good given the limitations of analog recording of the time. The original mono soundtracks are available as well. ---

Special Features:

What’s cool here is that we get the new digital visual effect which compliment the series in my opinion but update it in such a way that makes this vintage series more “contemporary” without losing the charm of the era it was made in. We also get the original visual effect using seamlessly branching software. You can switch between the original visual effects and the digital ones by using the angle button on your remote while watching the episode and even the visual effects themselves. It’s quite cool. ***

All of the previous special features from the most recent boxed set are here as well. Quoting from my earlier review: (FROM The HD/DVD review) “Interactive Enterprise Inspection” is the biggest difference between the HD & DVD versions. It’s a clever premise that doesn’t always take flight. You can take a shuttlecraft out and inspect the exterior of the Enterprise. The interactive menu has some problems to it that should have been fixed before this being issued but it’s likely they didn’t have the time or the money. It’s a nice feature that you might use one or two times. ***

Another big extra that is new to this set is “Starfleet Access” and that is available ONLY in the HD portion of the disc. There are seven episodes that receive this treatment where you can watch the episode while also watching behind-the-scenes footage and interviews related to the episodes. It’s a nice extra and is almost as illuminating as a commentary track. I’d rather have commentary tracks, however, on the episodes myself but it operates very much like the video commentary tracks on the film “Hellboy: Special Edition” and the second series of “Dr. Who” featuring David Tennant. They also could have done the same for the DVD portion of the discs but it would have eaten up a lot of disc space and made more discs necessary (for example “Dr. Who” often has only three episodes per disc when it has a video commentary). The result would have been more digital artifacts on the DVD side of the disc. I didn’t have time to watch all of these and, in fact, only watched them for “Where No Man Has Gone Before” and “Space Seed”. The former does feature actors Gary Lockwood and Sally Kellerman briefly discussing their role on the pivotal pilot episode of the series while the later features “Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan” scribe and producer Harve Bennett discussing the episode that provided the basis for his film sequel. Writer/producer Gene L. Coon who wrote the final teleplay is given recognition on this one as well which is nice. ***

“Billy Blackburn’s Treasure Chest: Rarely Seen Home Movies” is drawn from extra/actor Billy Blackburn’s 8mm home movies taken on the set during production. This is a gem. Blackburn was the helmsman that always stepped in Sulu wasn’t available or would often be beside Sulu. He was a consistent presence during the show’s run. Blackburn often played other characters as well in costume for the show. This is a really cool behind-the-scenes treat for fans of the series much like the home movies that were on the “Hogan’s Heroes” first two season box sets. ***

“Spacelift: Transporting Trek into the 21st Century features interviews with the Okudas, Rossi and others who executed the facelift for the show. We also see and hear about the remastering including the re-recording of the show’s theme and the digital clean up. ***

“Reflections on Spock” is new to this set. It features an interview with Nimoy discussing the character of Spock and the issues that surrounded the publication of his book I AM NOT SPOCK which started the rumors that he didn’t care for the character (which isn’t true). ***

“Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner” let’s us see Shatner’s other love besides acting, his wife and kids—riding horses. Shatner has been a companion breeder and competitor for some time. Some of this has been recycled from the previous set. ***

“To Boldly Go” is largely a recycled featurette on the series with interviews of Roddenberry conducted during “Star Trek: The Next Generation” run in the 80’s and interviews conducted with production crew such as Bob Justman for the original DVD Season One sets in 2004. ***

“Sci-Fi Visionaries” is also a recycled extra where producer Justman and story editor/writer Fontana discuss the science fiction writers that they hired to give the show the credibility it needed with a science fiction audience but, more importantly, distinguish “Star Trek” via its better writing, depth of characterization and imagination of the future. ***

“Star Trek: Beyond the Final Frontier” is a documentary that runs 90 minutes about the show hosted by Leonard Nimoy. Originally aired on the History Channel to help promote the Christie’s Auction of Trek memorabilia (from models to costumes), it’s a good documentary and one of the best new additions here. ***

“Kiss and Tell- Romance in the 23rd Century” is a brief featurette that looks at what Dr. McCoy complained about in “Star Trek VI”—Kirk’s never ending quest for the alien gal. -- - -

Final Words:

Well they finally got it right; “Star Trek: The Original Series” is presented with both the new digital visual effects AND the original vintage visual effects. You can toggle between the two. We also get all the previous extras from the HD/DVD set from last year. ***

All the special features from the previous set are included here. Is this worth it? It depends on how much of a Trekker you are but most fans will find this worthwhile.

 

 
 
 
Copyright @ Teakwood Productions 2000
Home News DVDWorld DVDLand(Links) DVDVoices
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer's Bio
Upcoming DVDs In Theatres Soon Other Popular Reviews
This Page Design By Dominion Technology Provider
 
In Theatres Soon Upcoming DVDs Alias Tomb Raider Casablanca NYPD Blues